Instagram Stories Vs Snapchat Stories: Who Wins?

Instagram Stories Is Better Than Snapchat Stories

Subscribe to our industry digest for the latest news and trends on top Instagrammers, YouTubers, bloggers, & Snapchatters!

Why Instagram Stories Is Better Than Snapchat Stories

Instagram recently launched a new feature called “Stories,” a secondary content feed which resembles Snapchat's defining, identically-named innovation in almost every way. From the content's ephemeral nature (like Snapchat Stories, Instagram Stories disappear after 24 hours) to tools that allow Instagram users to draw directly onto photos and videos (again, like Snapchat), Instagram Stories now places the competing platforms on an unavoidable collision course.

While it may be too early to predict how Instagram Stories will impact Snapchat (or how it will affect brands creating sponsored social media content on either platform), a cursory examination of Instagram's new feature shows that Instagram Stories are better than Snapchat's proprietary offering in a number of important ways.

Related Post: Facebook Copies Snapchat (Again) With Instagram Stories

Instagram Stories Smashbox Cosmetics Huda Beauty

Instagram influencer Huda Kattan showcases Smashbox Cosmetics' products for her 14.6M Instagram followers using the new Stories feature.

Instagram Stories Are Easily Discoverable With Search

Snapchat's lack of search functionality means finding content, friends, Snapchat stars, and brands is a constant challenge for Snapchat users. While Snapchat's "unsearchable" content may be appealing to some teenagers and millennials, brands, marketers, and prominent social media influencers have all expressed frustration at Snapchat Stories' limited reach.

Instagram Stories, by contrast, employs Instagram's search tool (which allows searches by people, hashtags, and places, as well as providing a general “Explore” option), thus making both content and users far more visible to audiences.

Related Post: How Influencers Help Brands Beat Low Instagram Engagement Rates

Instagram Has A Bigger Audience & Reach

With 500 million monthly active users (TechCrunch) and 300 million daily active users, Instagram currently offers a far more extensive reach compared to Snapchat (which only has 150 million daily active users). With Instagram Stories, Instagrammers and brands who have already amassed large audiences on the platforms can now expose followers to frequent posts and "in-the-moment" content without feeling the need to use Snapchat or spend time building a following on the app.

Related Post: The Most Impressive Instagram Statistics For 2016

Instagram Is More Friendly To Advertisers Than Snapchat

While Snapchat's popularity with teenage and millennial users makes the app a valuable marketing channel for brands, many marketers have griped about the high price of Snapchat advertising options (initial asking price of $750,000 vs. $50,000 commitment fee for Instagram) and Snapchat's reluctance to offer native advertising options (up until late) replete with traditional metrics, measurement, and campaign data (Digiday).

Both Facebook and Instagram, on the other hand, have spent years creating a robust and efficient advertising platform for brands. When the time comes for native advertising options on Instagram Stories (and it will), Instagram Stories will allow brands to take advantage of Instagram's extensive metrics, audience targeting options, call-to-action buttons, and more.

Instagram Stories Harry's Target

Target enlists Harry's founders Jeff and Andy to take over the brand's Instagram channel and ask social media audiences shaving-related questions via Instagram Stories.

Instagram Stories' Functionality Is Better Than Snapchat's

With near-limitless resources and a user base that dwarfs those of other social media platforms, Instagram's parent company, Facebook, has become adept at taking the best aspects of other platforms and/or apps (like Periscope, for example) and improving upon their original innovations or inventions. With Instagram Stories, Facebook attempted to differentiate the platform's new feature by bettering some of Snapchat’s functionalities in the following ways:

1. More Privacy Options

Instagram Stories includes a “Hide Story From” feature that allows users to keep their Stories from being seen by certain people (even if the Instagram account itself is public).

2. Algorithmic Reordering

Instagram Stories appear in a row at the top of an Instagram user's feed and are ordered using Instagram's algorithm—accounts that users interact with the most, therefore, appear closest to the beginning of the list. Snapchat Stories, by contrast, are ordered in reverse chronological order.

3. No Need To Follow Someone To See Content

Unlike Snapchat's functionality, Instagram users don’t have to be following someone to view their Instagram Stories. As long as an Instagrammer's Stories are public, they can be viewed by anyone who visits the user's page and clicks on their profile picture.

4. Hold Screen To Pause Function

Instagram users can hold the screen to pause an Instagram Stories slideshow and tap the left side to go back a slide (unlike Snapchat Stories, which constantly progress).

Instagram Stories Pizza Hut

Simple yet effective, Pizza Hut employs Instagram Stories' emojis to make audiences yearn for their own pizza party.

Are Snapchat's Original Features Enough To Save It?

While Instagram may have beaten Snapchat at its own game, Instagram Stories still lack some of Snapchat's most popular features, most notably: Instagram Stories doesn't alert users when viewers take a screenshot of their content, as Snapchat does; Instagram users can't tag their content with creative geofilters; and Instagram has not developed interactive lenses for Stories (though Facebook recently purchased MASQRD, a facial recognition face-swap program, suggests that it will).

If recent events are any indication, Instagram will likely continue adding new features (as well as advertising options) to Instagram Stories to draw social media audiences away from Snapchat, perhaps even permanently.

Also See Our Posts On:

10 Steps To Creating A Winning Influencer Marketing Strategy

The Most Popular Instagram Influencers For 2016

A Timeline Of Snapchat Ads, Innovation, & Growth

5 Steps For Developing And Instagram Influencer Marketing Campaign

August 3, 2016 By Mediakix Team

  • Kyle Gold

    As someone with clients I help to adapt and innovate in the social space, the lack of a Facebook Payments integration on Instagram continues to frustrate. The Snapcash feature is currently our only/best option when members of the millennial and hip gen-X/Y demos are the target audience…
    If Instagram added that feature, they would probably take pole position in several of our current/future campaigns.

Contact us

Use the contact form below to send us an email

Learn More Find Out How We Can Create a Custom Campaign to Fit Your Needs

Mediakix builds custom influencer campaigns, and will help you reach your target audiences in innovative and effective ways.

Phone: 310-450-1999
Address: 137 Bay St., Unit 3 Santa Monica, CA 90405